Most Singaporeans default to flying to KL. It's the obvious choice — 75 minutes in the air beats a four-hour-plus train ride, so why would anyone think twice? I did. And the moment I actually put ETS and flight prices side by side, the "obvious choice" stopped looking so obvious.
Economy ETS Seat: RM110 vs a Scoot seat
An ETS ticket runs about RM110 one-way. At today's exchange rate (roughly RM3.18 to S$1), that converts to S$34.60.
A Scoot flight on the same route is currently pricing around S$83 one-way for a standard economy seat, before baggage or seat selection are added on.
That's a gap of about S$48.40 — the train comes in 58% cheaper.
Business ETS Seat: RM165 vs an SIA seat
Same story at the top end. ETS Business Class — extra legroom, wider seats, priority boarding — costs RM165, or S$51.90.
A Singapore Airlines economy seat on the same route runs about S$220.
That's S$168.10 saved, or 76% cheaper — and worth noting, that's the ETS's premium class against SIA's standard one. There's no equivalent luxury tier on the rail side; RM165 is about as good as the train gets, and it's still cheaper than a basic plane seat. (SIA fares can also climb well past S$220 depending on season — so on some dates, the gap is bigger than this.)
The Opportunity Cost of Time
- Journey Time to Changi Airport (MRT via Tanah Merah): 40m
- Arrive ahead of check-in: 1h 30m
- Flight time (SIN–KUL): 1h 15m
- Immigration + baggage at KLIA: ~20m
- KLIA to KL city centre by car: 1h 00m
- Total: 4h 45m
🚆 Train (Location → Woodlands Checkpoint → ETS):
- To Woodlands Checkpoint: ~1hr 15 m
- Immigration clearance + crossing, both nodes: 20m
- Walk CIQ to JB Sentral and Boarding: ~20m
- ETS, JB Sentral to KL Sentral: 4h 20m
- KL Sentral to KL city centre by car: 15m
- Total: 6h 30m
No comments:
Post a Comment